Skip to content

How Plum Deluxe grew
its dormant Faire book 5X
in its first month

I'm glad to see that we're seeing positive impact right out of the gate.

Case studies/Plum Deluxe
Loose-leaf teaSep 2026
Plum Deluxe logoAndy Hayes, Founder, Plum Deluxe
Key highlights
    5X

    revenue from the dormant stores they handed over

    Jun 2026 vs Dec 2025–May 2026 avg

    60+

    stores back after 90+ days quiet

    Jun–Sep 2026

    40+

    of them quiet over a year

    Jun–Sep 2026

Plum Deluxe tea pouches with apples, a candle and honey
Plum Deluxe logoPlum Deluxe×Opener.
About Plum Deluxe

Tea blends built for a moment of calm

Plum Deluxe blends loose-leaf tea in Oregon. Founder Andy Hayes started with a travel blog, after trips through Scotland and the Netherlands, and turned it into tea. Today they sell direct, run a tea club, and wholesale to gift shops, cafes and specialty stores, many of them on Faire.

Andy Hayes, Plum Deluxe's founder, holding a bowl of loose-leaf tea
Andy Hayes, Plum Deluxe's founder. Photo: plumdeluxe.com
The challenge

The core book had a team. The quiet tail had no one.

Plum Deluxe's own team works the active Faire accounts. 900+ of their 1,000+ stores in their Faire book had ordered before, then gone quiet.

  • A long tail gone dark. About 490 days, on average, since those stores last ordered.
  • Close to zero. The quiet book sold almost nothing from February to May 2026.
  • Stale contacts. Years-old emails and numbers. The agents added or fixed 172 contacts in month one just to reach people.

On the dormant accounts, before Opener started:

“They probably will never come back.”
Andy Hayes, Plum Deluxe, July 2026
The solution

An AI agent on every quiet store

In June, Plum Deluxe handed Opener its 900+ quiet Faire accounts. Each one got its own agent, with our team reviewing every message before it goes out.

  • Wins back quiet stores. Faire messages, emails and calls to stores that stopped ordering months or years ago.
  • Switches channels when one is dead. One buyer's email was dead, so the agent moved to Faire Messenger. The store reordered the next day.
  • Writes to one store, not a list. Each note is written for that store. Andy: “these are much more impactful than the broadcast messages.”
A Plum Deluxe stockist Last order: September 2022
Quiet 1,500+ daysReordered · Sep 26, 2026
Buyer, specialty gift shop (on Faire) “I really was trying to hold off for Fall Teas, but strawberry shortcake did me in lol. I had to have them.”
Quiet 144 daysReordered twice
A row of Plum Deluxe tea pouches on a counter
Plum Deluxe blends, ready for the shelf. Photo: plumdeluxe.com
The results

Stores they'd written off are ordering again

5X

revenue from the dormant stores they handed over

Jun 2026 vs prior 6-month avg

60+

stores back after 90+ days quiet

Jun–Sep 2026

40+

of them had been quiet over a year

Jun–Sep 2026

In month one, their core Faire book, which Opener didn't touch, held its trend at +7%. Ten of the revived stores have already ordered more than once.

Plum Deluxe Spicy Caramel Apple herbal tea with apples and fall flowers
Spicy Caramel Apple, one of the fall blends. Photo: plumdeluxe.com
54 stores ordered through their agent. How long had each been quiet?
Stores with an agent-generated order, Jun 11 – Sep 28, 2026, by days since their previous invoice.

Every store. Its own agent.

A scoop of Plum Deluxe Apple Butter herbal tea, loose leaf

Plum Deluxe logo and images from plumdeluxe.com, used with permission. Figures are from Opener's order data for the Faire stores Plum Deluxe assigned to Opener, Jun 10 – Sep 28, 2026 (month-one comparison: June 2026 vs. the Dec 2025–May 2026 monthly average), and were approved by Plum Deluxe. The buyer quote is from a Faire message and is shared without the store's name.